Public Affair

Smashing it: glass causes concern for Wales DRS

By Julie Fourcade – Head of External Affairs and Internal Communications, FCC Environment.

The Welsh Government recently launched a consultation on its updated proposals to introduce a Deposit Return Scheme (DRS). Like in England and Scotland, the introduction of a DRS in Wales hasn’t been without controversy, with Welsh Government initially looking to introduce it ahead of the UK, but in July announced its intention to align its introduction with the rest of the UK.

However, some controversial issues remain. None more so than the introduction of glass packaging, a move that sets Wales apart from the rest of the UK. It’s a move that some producers have labelled as ‘muddled’, with no initial deposit on glass it has been questioned what incentive the public will have to take their glass bottles to a reverse vending machine instead of recycling them at the kerbside.

In a recent analysis of food price inflation, the Bank of England highlighted Extender Producer Responsibility as a contributor to increased food costs. Producers have been quick to warn that including glass in the scheme could have similar consequences for Welsh consumers as they are forced to include specific labelling for products sold in Wales.

One of the reasons glass packaging is being included in the scheme is due to Welsh Government’s proposal to introduce the reuse of materials into the DRS. The Welsh Government will publish a reuse roadmap, setting out key milestones for 2031, 2035 and 2045 for the percentage of drinks containers that are collected for reuse.

The proposals have been tailored to help grow the collecting, sorting and cleaning of reuseable bottles and avoid operational issues like that experienced in Ireland during the early stages of its DRS scheme. Recently, it was revealed that Irish consumers failed to claim back up to €66.7 million in drink container deposits throughout 2024. Welsh Government must consider new, innovative solutions to avoid similar issues and teething problems. 

A new Deposit Management Organisation (DMO) will manage the new scheme, who will also work with the drinks industry to develop an easy-to-find return point network. With proposed collection targets of 90% set for the third year of the scheme, it is vital that consumers have easy access to meet these targets and ensure all reuseable and recyclable drink containers are filtered through the new return scheme. 

Wales already has one of the best recycling rates in the world, coming second behind Austria. It does beg the question that despite its best intentions is the Welsh Government overcomplicating a policy that could mean disruption for the public and retailers, without really shifting the dial on recycling rates?