Public Affair

New Persistent Organic Pollution guidance goes pop

Last month the Environment Agency (EA) issued new guidance on how soft furnishings – such as sofas and armchairs – containing Persistent Organic Pollutants (POPs) should be managed. It’s safe to say the updated guidance has not been met with much enthusiasm from the waste management sector, with both the Environmental Services Association (ESA) and the Local Authority Recycling Advisory Committee (LARAC) raising concerns about the change in guidance.

What happened?

The EA wrote to all local authorities to issue the new guidance following an investigation that found significant levels of POPs in soft furnishings. Effective immediately, the new guidance stated that such products should not be landfilled, mixed with waste streams containing non-POPs, reused or recycled. Essentially, this means leaving all POPs-affected seating to be treated at energy from waste (EFW) facilities.

It is important to note that like other waste operators, FCC Environment is fully supportive of the need to ensure the safe, effective and appropriate management of the disposal of POPs waste. However, there are clear concerns shared among operators that the guidance is not achievable and could cause a number of problems in the short-term, particularly with ‘orphan waste’.

Is there enough EFW capacity?

One of the key issues industry has with the change in guidance is the lack of capacity to deal with this new waste stream. It is not known currently how much additional waste would need to be diverted to EFW facilities, but several hundred thousand tonnes each year is thought to be a good estimate. However, there is currently not enough spare capacity within the existing EFW network to deal with such a large increase in demand, with the majority of capacity tied to existing contractual arrangements between local authorities and waste operators.

To compound the issue further, before such waste can be treated at EFW facilities it requires shredding for operational and compliance reasons. The shredders already in operation across the UK are unlikely to comply with the new regulations set out by the EA, as it is difficult to guarantee that contaminated POPs waste and non-contaminated waste would be able to be kept separate. This would result in the requirement for additional shredding facilities – which of course need additional investment and development. Shredders alone cost around £500,000, and establishing the infrastructure required to meet the new POPs guidance will take at least a year given that the development period for facilities requiring the necessary ventilation upgrades and EA permitting timescales is currently in excess of 12 months. Given that the guidance was effective immediately as of last month, this can only mean a mounting orphan waste problem in the short-term.

Does it make sense to keep POPs waste separate?

Good regulation should be risk-based and proportionate. To me, the new guidance issued by the EA does not seem proportionate. One of the main questions I’ve been asking myself – and the EA – is whether it’s proportional to keep POPs waste and non-POPs waste separate at household waste recycling centres (HWRCs) and waste transfer stations if they are destined to be mixed once they reach an EFW facility?

It is also quite unlikely that all HWRCs have the required space to be able to be able to provide separate storage for this waste stream. At FCC Environment, our analysis has shown that only half of our HWRCs would be able to fit another skip to accommodate this waste. This leaves a real risk that we may have to remove another container to make space, potentially reducing the services we’re able to offer at that HWRC.

The move by the EA has undoubtedly ruffled some feathers, and I am sure the sector would welcome a reconsideration, with consultation on the guidance so that views can be properly articulated and considered by the EA before the new guidance then comes into effect. If the EA does plan on pushing ahead with the new guidance, we, along with other colleagues in the sector are of the firm belief that there needs to a minimum 12-month grace period before the guidance comes into force, to allow the sector to get the necessary infrastructure in order.

 


Julie Fourcade, Head of External Affairs